← Home
The Heroic Enthusiasts, Part I (Gli Eroici Furori) · 39 of 63 · tr. L. Williams

Fourth Dialoguef

Hence it follows that not less do we desire to see things unknown and unseen than those known and seen. And from this it does not follow that the desire does not proceed from cognition, and that we desire something that is not known; but I say that it is certain and sure that we do not desire unknown things. Because, if they be occult as to particulars, they are not occult as to generals; as in the entire visual power is found the whole of the visible appositely, and in the intellect all the intelligible. Therefore, as the inclination to the act lies in its appropriateness, the result is that both these powers incline towards the universal action, as to a thing naturally comprehended as good. The soul, then, did not speak to the deaf or the blind when she counselled her thoughts to repress the sight, which, although it may not be the immediate cause of the will, is yet the primal and principal cause. Cic . What do you mean by this last saying? Tans . I mean that it is not the figure or the conception, sensibly or intelligently represented, which of itself moves us; because while one stands beholding the figure manifested to the eyes, he does not yet arrive at loving; but from that instant that the soul conceives within itself that figure, not visible, but thinkable; no longer dividual, but individual; no longer classed among things in general, but among things good and beautiful; then immediately love is born. Now this is the seeing, from which the soul desires to divert the eyes of her thoughts. Here the sight usually moves the affection to a greater love than the love of that which is seen; for, as I have just said, it always considers, through the universal knowledge that it holds of the beautiful and the good, that, besides the degrees of known conceptions of goodness and beauty, there are others and yet others ad infinitum . Cic . How is it that after we become informed of that conception of the beautiful which is begotten in the soul, we yet desire to satisfy the exterior vision? Tans . From this, that the soul would ever love that which it loves, and ever see that which it sees. Therefore she wills that, the conception which has been produced in her through seeing, should not become weakened, enervated and lost; but would ever see more and more, and that which becomes obscure in the interior affection, should be frequently brightened by the exterior aspect, which as it is the principle of being, must also be the principle of conservation. This results proportionately in the act of understanding and of considering, for as the sight has reference to visible things, so has the intellect to intelligible things. I believe now that you understand to what end and in what manner the soul tends, when she says "repress the sight." Cic . I understand very well. Now continue to unfold what happens to these thoughts. Tans . Now follows the disagreement between the mother and the aforesaid children, who having, contrary to her orders, opened their eyes, and, having fixed them on the splendour of the object, they remained in company with the heart. 22. Cruel sons are ye to me, me whom ye left Still farther to exasperate my pain; And ever without cease ye weary me, Taking away from me my every hope! Why should the sense remain? oh, grasping heavens! Wherefore these broken ruined powers, if not To make me subject and exemplar Of such heavy martyrdom, such lengthened pain? Leave, dear sons, my winged fire enchained, And let me, some of you once more behold, Come back to me from those retaining claws! Oh, weariness! not one returns To bring a late refreshment to my pains.
Themes
◆Anamnesissoteriology

Platonic recollection: knowledge as the soul's recovery of what it knew before birth, with learning as remembering rather than acquisition.

The text implies innate knowledge ('universal knowledge that it holds') where learning is a recovery of what is already within.

All passages →
◆Correspondencecosmology

The Hermetic axiom that the structure of the cosmos is reflected at every scale — 'as above, so below; as within, so without' — making each level a legible map of the others.

The text states 'as the sight has reference to visible things, so has the intellect to intelligible things', establishing a structural parallel.

All passages →
◆Detachment Gelassenheitpraxis

Eckhart's Abgeschiedenheit/Gelassenheit — radical letting-go of will, image, and grasping that opens the soul to God; distinct from inner_silence (quietness) and from material renunciation, and adjacent to Sufi tark and Buddhist non-grasping as a practice rather than a metaphysical claim.

The instruction to 'repress the sight' implies a letting-go of sensory attachment to access higher truth.

All passages →
◆Divine Intoxicationpraxis

Ecstatic, non-rational receptivity to the divine figured as drunkenness — Plato's symposium wine, Rumi's sukr, Eckhart's 'sober drunkenness'; the passive/receptive metaphor for divine encounter, distinct from divine_madness's active possessing rapture.

The title 'Heroic Enthusiasts' and the description of 'winged fire' align with ecstatic receptivity to the divine.

All passages →
◆Divine Madnesssoteriology

Ecstatic irrational rapture — Plato's mania, Bruno's furore — by which the soul transcends ordinary reason and attains direct contact with divine reality; madness reframed as higher knowledge.

The passage describes an ecstatic rapture ('enthusiasts', 'furori') where the soul transcends ordinary reason to attain divine reality.

All passages →
◆Divine Sparkscosmology

Fragments of divine light or spirit trapped inside material bodies, awaiting liberation and return to their source.

The 'winged fire enchained' within the soul suggests fragments of divine spirit trapped in the material condition.

All passages →
◆Gnosis Direct Knowledgesoteriology

Salvation through direct experiential knowledge of the divine nature, not through faith, ritual, or moral works alone.

Salvation or love arises from the 'universal knowledge that it holds' and direct conception within the soul.

All passages →
◆Inner Lightanthropology

The divine spark or luminous quality residing within the human person, potentially recognisable through introspection.

The 'winged fire enchained' within the soul suggests a divine luminous quality residing inside the human person.

All passages →
◆Inner Silencepraxis

The practice of stilling the mind and speech to open receptivity to divine knowledge or presence.

The soul counsels thoughts to 'repress the sight' and turn inward to conceive figures within itself.

All passages →
◆Kingdom Withinanthropology

The claim that the divine realm is present inside the individual, accessible without external mediation.

The text emphasizes that love and conception are born when the soul conceives the figure 'within itself' rather than externally.

All passages →
◆Ladder Of Lovesoteriology

Diotima's staged ascent from love of beautiful bodies → beautiful souls → beautiful pursuits → beautiful knowledge → Beauty itself; the canonical scala amoris that grounds Plotinus's On the Beautiful and Bruno's Eroici Furori — distinct from generic spiritual_ascent in that eros is the specific motive force.

The dialogue describes an ascent through 'degrees of known conceptions of goodness and beauty' toward the universal.

All passages →
◆Microcosm Macrocosmcosmology

The human being as a small-scale image of the entire cosmos; the body, soul, and intellect mirroring the structure of the heavens and the divine — distinct from correspondence in that it makes the human the privileged mirror.

The intellect is described as containing 'all the intelligible' just as visual power contains the visible, mirroring the cosmos within the soul.

All passages →
◆Mystical Unionsoteriology

The merging of the individual soul or self with the divine, transcending personal identity.

Love is born when the soul conceives the figure internally, suggesting a merging of the soul with the beautiful/good.

All passages →
◆Return To Sourcesoteriology

The soul's journey back to its divine origin, reversing the fall into matter through stages of purification or illumination.

The poem's plea 'Come back to me' and the desire to brighten interior affection imply a journey back to the divine origin.

All passages →
◆Self Knowledgesoteriology

The recognition of one's own true divine nature as the primary path to liberation; 'know thyself' as soteriology.

Turning inward to conceive the figure within oneself is presented as a path to understanding the good and beautiful.

All passages →
◆Separation From Sourcesoteriology

The felt condition of exile from one's divine origin — Rumi's reed flute torn from its bed, Plotinus's 'we have forgotten,' the Gnostic forgetfulness; the affective wound that complements return_to_source and gives the return its motive.

The poem expresses deep pain and longing ('Cruel sons... left... exasperate my pain') indicating a felt exile from the divine source.

All passages →
◆Spiritual Ascentpraxis

A staged journey of the soul upward through heavenly realms or levels of being toward the divine source.

The movement from exterior vision to interior conception and toward infinite degrees of beauty represents a staged upward journey.

All passages →
◇Active Contemplationpraxis

A form of meditation that uses imagery, imagination, or symbolic thought rather than purely empty stillness.

[auto] The passage emphasizes conceiving figures 'within itself' as thinkable and individual rather than relying on external sensory representation.

All passages →
◇Body As Obstacleanthropology

The material body viewed as a prison, tomb, or source of error that hinders spiritual knowledge and return.

[auto] The senses are described as 'broken ruined powers' causing pain, and the soul counsels to 'repress the sight' to focus inward.

All passages →
◇Divine Lighttheology

The uncreated luminous quality of the divine, sometimes experienced directly in mystical states; illumination as revelation.

[auto] References to 'splendour,' 'winged fire,' and brightening the interior affection align with the concept of divine illumination.

All passages →
◇Heroic Furorpraxis

Bruno's eroici furori — a passionate, ennobling spiritual ardor that drives the soul toward divine wisdom; distinguished from base or animal passions by its orientation to infinite truth.

[auto] The passage is from Bruno's work defining this concept, describing the soul's passionate drive ('winged fire') toward infinite truth and beauty.

All passages →
◇Infinite Cosmoscosmology

The doctrine of the universe as boundless and without center or circumference, populated by innumerable worlds — Bruno's rejection of the closed Aristotelian sphere; the divine and the cosmos as ontologically infinite.

[auto] The text explicitly mentions degrees of goodness and beauty extending 'ad infinitum,' reflecting Bruno's doctrine of ontological infinity.

All passages →
◇Paradox As Teachingethics

Using apparent contradiction, reversal, or riddle to destabilise ordinary understanding and induce insight.

[auto] The opening argument presents a paradox where we desire the unknown yet do not desire things that are truly unknown to cognition.

All passages →
Related passages · 28 parallels
◆christian_mysticism|Pseudo-Dionysius: The Divine Names|Chapter 7, Section 1d
“Furthermore, we must ask how it is that we know God when He cannot be perceived by the mind or the senses and is not a particular Being. Perhaps ‘tis true to say that we know not God by His Nature (for this is unknowable and beyond the rea…”
Both passages explore the relationship between human cognition and the divine, emphasizing that while the divine is ultimately unknowable in its essence, it can be apprehended through its manifestations and effects in the world. They both discuss the limitations of sensory and intellectual perception in understanding the divine.
◆christian_mysticism|The Life and Doctrines of Jacob Boehme|Chapter 1 (part 4)
“Let them, therefore, again go out with their will from their wilful ignorance or malignity and enter again into the will of God." ( Menschwerdung , 3, 5.) All this goes to show that it is useless and vain to seek for divine wisdom, meaning…”
Both passages discuss the idea of inner vision and the limitations of external perception in understanding higher truths. They emphasize the need to look beyond the physical and sensory to grasp the universal and the divine.
◆christian_mysticism|The Life and Doctrines of Jacob Boehme|Chapter 2 (part 5)
“The will beholding itself in the mirror of wisdom causes its own image to appear within the groundlessness, and thus it creates a foundation in its own imagination." ( Menschwerdung , ii. 1.) "Wisdom, the eternal virgin, the playmate of Go…”
Both passages explore the interplay between the will, desire, and the manifestation of divine or universal truths. They discuss the role of perception and the will in revealing deeper realities, though they come from different mystical traditions.
◆christian_mysticism|The Life and Doctrines of Jacob Boehme|Chapter 3 (part 4)
“The will cannot attain this light, and the more it desires for freedom the greater will be the attraction caused by the desire." ( Six Theosophical Points , i, 38.) "There must be au opposition, for the will desires not to be dark, and this…”
Both passages explore the tension between desire and its consequences, highlighting the internal struggle within the human will. They discuss how the pursuit of freedom or knowledge leads to a form of anguish or disquietude, reflecting a deep conceptual parallel across different mystical traditions.
◆neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 43
“Section 10 10. Perhaps the reason this continuous activity remains unperceived is that it has no touch whatever with things of sense. No doubt action upon material things, or action dictated by them, must proceed through the sensitive facul…”
Both passages explore the nature of perception and the higher, intellectual or spiritual faculties that operate beyond sensory experience. They discuss the idea that true understanding or love arises from internal, intellectual apprehension rather than external sensory input.
◆neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 65
“Section 4 4. But there are earlier and loftier beauties than these. In the sense-bound life we are no longer granted to know them, but the soul, taking no help from the organs, sees and proclaims them. To the vision of these we must mount,…”
Both passages discuss the nature of beauty and the soul's perception of it, emphasizing the higher, spiritual beauty that transcends physical senses. They share a mystical perspective on the soul's ability to perceive and be moved by this higher beauty.
◆neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 66 (part 1)
“Section 5 5. These Lovers, then, lovers of the beauty outside of sense, must be made to declare themselves. What do you feel in presence of the grace you discern in actions, in manners, in sound morality, in all the works and fruits of vi…”
Both passages discuss the nature of desire and the soul's inclination towards the beautiful and the good. They emphasize the soul's ability to perceive universal truths beyond the immediate sensory experience, highlighting the deeper, intellectual appreciation of beauty and goodness.
◆neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 172 (part 2)
“Now, if the sight of Beauty excellently reproduced upon a face hurries the mind to that other Sphere, surely no one seeing the loveliness lavish in the world of sense- this vast orderliness, the Form which the stars even in their remoteness…”
Both passages discuss the concept of perceiving beauty and how it leads the soul to a higher understanding or recollection of a greater reality. They share a mystical perspective on the relationship between sensory experience and spiritual insight.
◆neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 273
“Section 7 7. Certain Principles, then, we may take to be established- some self-evident, others brought out by our treatment above: All the forms of Authentic Existence spring from vision and are a vision. Everything that springs from these…”
Both passages explore the theme of vision and knowledge as fundamental drives, with a focus on the pursuit of ideal forms or universal truths. They share a mystical perspective on the nature of existence and the soul's desire for contemplation and understanding.
◆neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 345
“Section 25 25. But the organ is not the only requisite to vision or to perception of any kind: there must be a state of the soul inclining it towards the sphere of sense. Now it is the soul's character to be ever in the Intellectual sphere,…”
Both passages discuss the nature of perception and the soul's inclination towards higher intellectual or spiritual realms. They explore the idea that sensory perception can be a distraction from higher understanding and the soul's desire to focus on the universal and the good.
18 more
◆neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 422 (part 2)
“But in soul the utterance is obscured, for soul is an image and must look to its own original: that Principle, on the contrary, looks to the First without mediation- thus becoming what it is- and has that vision not as from a distance but a…”
Both passages discuss the soul's longing for a higher, more perfect reality. Passage A describes the soul's desire to connect with the First Principle, while Passage B discusses the soul's desire to see and understand things beyond the immediate and visible, seeking the universal good and beautiful.
◆neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 428
“Section 12 12. Possessed of such powers, how does it happen that we do not lay hold of them, but for the most part, let these high activities go idle- some, even, of us never bringing them in any degree to effect? The answer is that all the…”
Both passages discuss the inner perception and attention required to access higher spiritual or intellectual realms. They emphasize the need to turn inward and focus on higher truths beyond mere sensory perception.
◆neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 440 (part 1)
“Section 8 8. Now comes the question what sort of thing does the Intellectual-Principle see in seeing the Intellectual Realm and what in seeing itself? We are not to look for an Intellectual realm reminding us of the colour or shape to be…”
Both passages explore the nature of intellectual or divine vision and the unity of the seer and the seen. They discuss the transcendence of the intellectual realm and the soul's relationship with it, though they come from different mystical traditions.
◆neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 461
“Section 8 8. So that we are left wondering whence it came, from within or without; and when it has gone, we say, "It was here. Yet no; it was beyond!" But we ought not to question whence; there is no whence, no coming or going in place; now…”
Both passages discuss the nature of divine vision and the intellect's role in perceiving the divine. They explore the idea of the soul's desire to see and understand the divine, emphasizing the transcendence and immediacy of the divine presence.
◆neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 463
“Section 10 10. Still, do not, I urge you, look for The Good through any of these other things; if you do, you will see not itself but its trace: you must form the idea of that which is to be grasped cleanly standing to itself not in any com…”
Both passages explore the nature of The Good and the intellect's relationship to it. They discuss the limitations of human perception and the desire to comprehend the divine or the ultimate good, which is beyond ordinary understanding.
◆neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 465
“Section 12 12. Knowing demands the organ fitted to the object; eyes for one kind, ears for another: similarly some things, we must believe, are to be known by the Intellectual-Principle in us. We must not confuse intellection with hearing o…”
Both passages explore the nature of desire and the pursuit of the Good and the Beautiful, discussing their hierarchical relationship and the soul's inclination towards them. They share a mystical perspective on the primacy of the Good over Beauty and the soul's longing for the divine.
◆neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 708
“Section 4 4. The main part of the difficulty is that awareness of this Principle comes neither by knowing nor by the Intellection that discovers the Intellectual Beings but by a presence overpassing all knowledge. In knowing, soul or mind a…”
Both passages discuss the limitations of knowledge and the intellect in attaining a higher, mystical understanding. They emphasize the need to transcend ordinary perception and cognition to achieve a direct, unmediated experience of the divine or ultimate reality.
◆platonism|Plato: Phaedo|Section 1n
“For this is clear, that when we perceived something, either by the help of sight or hearing, or some other sense, there was no difficulty in receiving from this a conception of some other thing like or unlike which had been forgotten and wh…”
Both passages explore the concept of pre-existence and the soul's knowledge of abstract concepts like beauty and goodness. Plato's Phaedo discusses the theory of recollection, suggesting that learning is a process of remembering what the soul knew before birth. The Fourth Dialogue similarly discusses the soul's innate knowledge and its desire to perceive and understand universal truths, indicating a pre-existing cognitive capacity.
◆platonism|Plato: Phaedo|Section 1r
“And this, my friend, may be conceived to be that heavy, weighty, earthy element of sight by which such a soul is depressed and dragged down again into the visible world, because she is afraid of the invisible and of the world below-prowling…”
Both passages explore the concept of the soul's journey and its relationship with the physical and spiritual realms. They discuss the soul's desire to transcend the physical and the role of vision in this process, though they use different metaphors and frameworks.
◆platonism|Plato: Republic|Section 1c
“I do not say heaven, lest you should fancy that I am playing upon the name ('ourhanoz, orhatoz'). May I suppose that you have this distinction of the visible and intelligible fixed in your mind? I have. Now take a line which has been cut…”
Both passages discuss the nature of perception and the distinction between the visible and intelligible realms. They explore the idea of the soul's journey from the physical to the metaphysical, using hypotheses and images to understand higher truths.
◆platonism|Plato: Republic|Section 1c
“Moreover, I said, you must not wonder that those who attain to this beatific vision are unwilling to descend to human affairs; for their souls are ever hastening into the upper world where they desire to dwell; which desire of theirs is ver…”
Both passages discuss the nature of perception and the soul's desire to move beyond the physical to comprehend higher truths. They explore the idea that the soul seeks to understand universal concepts of beauty and goodness, and that the physical senses can both aid and distract from this pursuit.
◆western_esoteric|Tertium Organum (P.D. Ouspensky)|Chapter IV (part 3)
“If, presupposing that we are moving upon a sphere, upon its equator or one of its parallels, then it will appear that we recognize as really existing only one meridian: those which are behind us have disappeared and those ahead of us have n…”
Both passages explore the limitations of human perception and the desire for a higher, more comprehensive understanding. Passage A discusses the idea of an expanded consciousness that can perceive the past, present, and future simultaneously, while Passage B talks about the soul's desire to see and understand things beyond immediate sensory perception.
◆western_esoteric|Tertium Organum (P.D. Ouspensky)|Chapter IX (part 2)
“This happens because we never feel anything at a long distance, and the eye has not been taught to discern the difference in surfaces which at short distances are felt by the finger-tips. 1 p. 100 We can never see, even in the minute, any…”
Both passages explore the limitations of human perception and the distortions introduced by our senses. They discuss how our understanding of reality is mediated by our sensory experiences and the need to go beyond mere sensory input to grasp a deeper truth.
◆western_esoteric|Tertium Organum (P.D. Ouspensky)|Chapter XIV (part 3)
“Therefore, the first emotion at the rising of the curtain on "that world"—i.e., this our world, but free of those limitations under which we usually regard it—must be of wonderment , and this wonderment must grow greater and greater accordi…”
Both passages explore the idea of perceiving deeper, hidden realities beyond the superficial. They emphasize the importance of recognizing subtle differences and understanding the noumenal or universal aspects of phenomena, which aligns with mystical traditions' focus on inner knowledge and perception.
◆western_esoteric|Tertium Organum (P.D. Ouspensky)|Chapter XIV (part 4)
“He hears "the voices of stones," understands the whisperings of ancient walls, of tumuli, of mountains, rivers, woods and plains. He hears " the voice of the silence ," understands the psychological difference between silences, knows that…”
Both passages explore the idea of perceiving deeper realities beyond the surface phenomena. They emphasize the role of the soul or artistic vision in understanding the hidden aspects of existence, though they come from different mystical traditions.
◆western_esoteric|Tertium Organum (P.D. Ouspensky)|Chapter XIX (part 7)
“In the reduction of your soul to its simplest self, its divine essence, you realize this union—this identity. But this sublime condition is not of permanent duration. It is only now and then that we can enjoy this elevation above the limi…”
Both passages explore the concept of the soul's desire to perceive and understand the divine or the infinite. They discuss the elevation of the mind and the soul's journey towards union with the divine, highlighting the limitations of sensory perception and the higher nature of spiritual insight.
◆western_esoteric|Tertium Organum (P.D. Ouspensky)|Chapter XXII (part 8)
“Permanency also suffers no change of its nature, because it is not mingled with the unstable. And the beautiful there is beautiful, because it does not subsist in beauty (as in a subject). Each thing too is there p. 280 established, not…”
Both passages explore the nature of perception and the soul's desire for understanding and contemplation of the beautiful and the good. They discuss the relationship between the soul's inner vision and the external world, emphasizing the insatiable nature of the soul's quest for knowledge and the unity of perception and being.
◆western_esoteric|Tertium Organum (P.D. Ouspensky)|Chapter XXII (part 16)
“Having become indifferent to objects of perception, the pupil must seek out the Rajah of the senses, the Thought-Producer, him who awakes illusions. The mind is the great slayer of the real. Let the Disciple slay the Slayer. For— When to…”
Both passages discuss the idea of transcending sensory perception to attain a higher, more spiritual understanding. They emphasize the need to look beyond the physical and the known to grasp the universal and the divine.