← Home
The Writings of Chuang Tzu (Inner Chapters) · 53 of 57 · tr. James Legge

Book 129 (part 1)

p. 259 BOOK VII. PART I. SECTION VII. Ying Tî Wang 1 , or 'The Normal Course for Rulers and Kings 1 .' 1. Nieh Khüeh 2 put four questions to Wang Î 2 , not one of which did he know (how to answer). On this Nieh Khüeh leaped up, and in great delight walked away and informed Phû-î-dze 3 of it, who said to him, 'Do you (only) now know it? He of the line of Yü 4 was not equal to him of the line of Thâi 5 . He of Yü still kept in himself (the idea of) benevolence by which to constrain (the submission of) men; and he did win men, but he had not begun to proceed by what did not belong to him as a man. He of the line of Thâi would sleep tranquilly, and awake in contented simplicity. He would consider himself now (merely) as a horse, and now (merely) as an ox 6 . His knowledge was real and untroubled p. 260 by doubts; and his virtue was very true:--he had not begun to proceed by what belonged to him as a man. 2. Kien Wû 1 went to see the mad (recluse), Khieh-yü 2 , who said to him, 'What did Zäh-kung Shih 3 tell you?' The reply was, 'He told me that when rulers gave forth their regulations according to their own views and enacted righteous measures, no one would venture not to obey them, and all would be transformed.' Khieh-yd said, 'That is but the hypocrisy of virtue. For the right ordering of the world it would be like trying to wade through the sea and dig through the Ho, or employing a musquito to carry a mountain on its back. And when a sage is governing, does he govern men's outward actions? He is (himself) correct, and so (his government) goes on;--this is the simple and certain way by which he secures the success of his affairs. Think of the bird which flies high, to avoid being hurt by the dart on the string of the archer, and the little mouse which makes its hole deep under Shän-khiû 4 to avoid the danger of being smoked or dug out;-are (rulers) less knowing than these two little creatures?' 3. Thien Kän 5 , rambling on the south of (mount) Yin 6 , came to the neighbourhood of the Liâo-water. p. 261 Happening there to meet with the man whose name is not known 1 , he put a question to him, saying, 'I beg to ask what should be done 2 in order to (carry on) the government of the world.' The nameless man said, 'Go away; you are a rude borderer. Why do you put to me a question for which you are unprepared 3 ? I would simply play the part of the Maker of (all) things 4 . When wearied, I would mount on the bird of the light and empty air, proceed beyond the six cardinal points, and wander in the region of nonentity, to dwell in the wilderness of desert space. What method have you, moreover, for the government of the world that you (thus) agitate my mind?' (Thien Kän), however, again asked the question, and the nameless man said, 'Let your mind find its enjoyment in pure simplicity; blend yourself with (the primary) ether in idle indifference; allow all things to take their natural course; and admit no personal or selfish consideration:--do this and the world will be governed.' 4.
Themes
Gnosis Direct Knowledgesoteriology

Salvation through direct experiential knowledge of the divine nature, not through faith, ritual, or moral works alone.

The text praises knowledge that is real and untroubled by doubts over learned regulations.

All passages →
Hidden Sayingssoteriology

Esoteric teachings reserved for those ready to receive them; outer meaning conceals an inner liberating truth.

The truth is conveyed through the lack of an answer rather than explicit instruction.

All passages →
Inner Silencepraxis

The practice of stilling the mind and speech to open receptivity to divine knowledge or presence.

The sage is described as sleeping tranquilly, indicating a state of internal stillness.

All passages →
Kingdom Withinanthropology

The claim that the divine realm is present inside the individual, accessible without external mediation.

Virtue is described as being kept in himself rather than imposed externally.

All passages →
Return To Sourcesoteriology

The soul's journey back to its divine origin, reversing the fall into matter through stages of purification or illumination.

The comparison between the lineages of Yü and Thâi implies a return to a more primal, natural state.

All passages →
Apophatic Theologytheology

Describing the divine only by negation—God transcends all positive categories and concepts; the via negativa.

[auto] Wang Î's inability to answer questions signifies that the ultimate truth transcends verbal concepts and categories.

All passages →
Mystical Unionsoteriology

The merging of the individual soul or self with the divine, transcending personal identity.

[auto] The sage considers himself a horse or an ox, indicating a merging of self-identity with nature and the Tao.

All passages →
Opposites Transcendedanthropology

The dissolution of binary oppositions (male/female, inner/outer, above/below) as a mark of spiritual completion.

[auto] The sage transcends the binary of human versus animal identity and knowing versus not knowing.

All passages →
Paradox As Teachingethics

Using apparent contradiction, reversal, or riddle to destabilise ordinary understanding and induce insight.

[auto] The passage centers on the delight found in not knowing how to answer questions, using this silence to destabilize ordinary understanding.

All passages →
Rejection Of Hypocrisyethics

Critique of outward religious observance that lacks inner transformation; form without substance.

[auto] The passage critiques rulers who use benevolence to constrain men versus the natural virtue of Thâi.

All passages →
Self Knowledgesoteriology

The recognition of one's own true divine nature as the primary path to liberation; 'know thyself' as soteriology.

[auto] The text describes a state where knowledge is real and untroubled because the sage does not proceed by human constructs.

All passages →
Unity Of Beingtheology

The doctrine that all existence is ultimately one substance or one divine reality; non-duality as a theological claim.

[auto] The identification with animals suggests a non-dualistic view where the distinction between self and nature dissolves.

All passages →
Related passages · 6 parallels
greek_mystery|The Golden Verses of Pythagoras|Section 7 (part 1)
p. 29 THE PYTHAGOREAN SENTENCES OF DEMOPHILUS 1. Request not of Divinity such things as, when obtained, you cannot preserve; for no gift of Divinity can ever be taken away; and on this account he does not confer that which you are unable…”
Both passages explore themes of governance, virtue, and the nature of the divine or ultimate reality. They emphasize the importance of inner virtue and correct conduct over external regulations and rituals, reflecting a mystical approach to leadership and life.
neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 19 (part 1)
Section 1 1. Since Evil is here, "haunting this world by necessary law," and it is the Soul's design to escape from Evil, we must escape hence. But what is this escape? "In attaining Likeness to God," we read. And this is explained as "…”
Both passages explore the theme of governance and virtue, emphasizing the importance of inner virtue and alignment with a higher principle or divine being. They both critique external regulations and highlight the need for inner transformation and alignment with a higher order.
neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 210 (part 1)
Section 4 4. If man were all of one piece- I mean, if he were nothing more than a made thing, acting and acted upon according to a fixed nature- he could be no more subject to reproach and punishment than the mere animals. But as the sche…”
Both passages discuss the concept of governance and the role of a higher power or principle in ordering the universe. Plotinus speaks of a Providence as a general planning and ordering the universe, while the Taoist text discusses the ideal governance by rulers who align with natural principles and do not impose artificial constraints.
neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 210 (part 2)
The Reason-Principle of an ox does not occur except in connection with the Matter appropriate to the ox-Kind. It must be by such a process that the transmigration, of which we read takes place; the Soul must lose its nature, the Reason-Pri…”
Both passages explore the nature of individual responsibility and the role of a higher principle or creator in determining human qualities and actions. They discuss the limitations of human nature and the inevitability of inequality, though from different philosophical and religious perspectives.
neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 499
Section 7 7. Knowledge in the reasoning soul is on the one side concerned with objects of sense, though indeed this can scarcely be called knowledge and is better indicated as opinion or surface-knowing; it is of later origin than the objec…”
Both passages discuss the idea of individuals who rise above the mundane concerns of the world to attain a higher state of being or understanding. Plotinus describes those who see the 'splendour above' and return to their 'native land,' while the Taoist text speaks of those who sleep 'tranquilly' and awake in 'contented simplicity,' seeking to govern from a place of inner correctness.
platonism|Plato: Republic|Section 1k
But, said I, one is enough; let there be one man who has a city obedient to his will, and he might bring into existence the ideal polity about which the world is so incredulous. Yes, one is enough. The ruler may impose the laws and instit…”
Both passages discuss the qualities and challenges of ideal rulers. Plato emphasizes the rare combination of intelligence and virtue needed for a philosopher-king, while the Taoist text highlights the simplicity and natural virtue required for effective governance. Both traditions recognize the difficulty in finding such individuals.