← Home
The Writings of Chuang Tzu (Inner Chapters) · 41 of 57 · tr. James Legge

Book 128 (part 2)

Hence he who tries to share his joys with others is not a sagely man; he who manifests affection is not benevolent; he who observes times and seasons (to regulate his conduct) is not a man of wisdom; he to whom profit and injury are not the same is not a superior man; he who acts for the sake of the name of doing so, and loses his (proper) self is not the (right) scholar; and he who throws away his person in a way which is not the true (way) cannot command the service of others. Such men as Hû Pû-kieh, Wû Kwang, Po-î, Shû-khî, the count of Kî, Hsü-yü, Kî Thâ, and Shän-thû Tî, all did service for other men, and sought to secure for them what they desired, not seeking their own pleasure 2 . p. 240 4. The True men of old presented the aspect of judging others aright, but without being partisans; of feeling their own insufficiency, but being without flattery or cringing. Their peculiarities were natural to them, but they were not obstinately attached to them; their humility was evident, but there was nothing of unreality or display about it. Their placidity and satisfaction had the appearance of joy; their every movement seemed to be a necessity to them. Their accumulated attractiveness drew men's looks to them; their blandness fixed men's attachment to their virtue. They seemed to accommodate themselves to the (manners of their age), but with a certain severity; their haughty indifference was beyond its control. Unceasing seemed their endeavours to keep (their mouths) shut; when they looked down, they had forgotten what they wished to say. They considered punishments to be the substance (of government, and they never incurred it); ceremonies to be its supporting wings (and they always observed them); wisdom (to indicate) the time (for action, and they always selected it); and virtue to be accordance (with others), and they were all-accordant. Considering punishments to be the substance (of government), yet their generosity appeared in the (manner of their) infliction of death. Considering ceremonies to be its supporting wings, they pursued p. 241 by means of them their course in the world. Considering wisdom to indicate the time (for action), they felt it necessary to employ it in (the direction of) affairs. Considering virtue to be accordance (with others), they sought to ascend its height along with all who had feet (to climb it). (Such were they), and yet men really thought that they did what they did by earnest effort 1 . 5. In this way they were one and the same in all their likings and dislikings. Where they liked, they were the same; where they did not like, they were the same. In the former case where they liked, they were fellow-workers with the Heavenly (in them); in the latter where they disliked, they were coworkers with the Human in them. The one of these elements (in their nature) did not overcome the other. Such were those who are called the True men. Death and life are ordained, just as we have the constant succession of night and day;--in both cases from Heaven. Men have no power to do anything in reference to them;--such is the constitution of things 2 . There are those who specially regard Heaven 3 as their father, and they still love It (distant as It is) 3 ;--how much more should they love p. 242 That which stands out (Superior and Alone) 1 ! Some specially regard their ruler as superior to themselves, and will give their bodies to die for him; how much more should they do so for That which is their true (Ruler) 1 !
Themes
Inner Silencepraxis

The practice of stilling the mind and speech to open receptivity to divine knowledge or presence.

The description of 'placidity and satisfaction' suggests a state of mental stillness characteristic of the True Men.

All passages →
Wu Weipraxis

Effortless action aligned with the spontaneous flow of the Dao; non-coercive, non-striving conduct that yields results without forcing — the sage acts without acting.

The description of True Men whose movements seem like necessity and who act without earnest effort aligns with the concept of effortless action.

All passages →
Opposites Transcendedanthropology

The dissolution of binary oppositions (male/female, inner/outer, above/below) as a mark of spiritual completion.

[auto] The passage explicitly states that for the superior man, profit and injury are not the same, indicating a dissolution of binary oppositions.

All passages →
Paradox As Teachingethics

Using apparent contradiction, reversal, or riddle to destabilise ordinary understanding and induce insight.

[auto] The text uses negations of conventional virtues, such as claiming observing seasons is not wisdom, to destabilize ordinary understanding.

All passages →
Rejection Of Hypocrisyethics

Critique of outward religious observance that lacks inner transformation; form without substance.

[auto] It critiques those who act for the sake of name or display unreality, emphasizing natural humility without performance.

All passages →
Related passages · 9 parallels
buddhism|The Dhammapada|Chapter XII, Section 1
p. 45 CHAPTER XII. SELF. 157. If a man hold himself dear, let him watch himself carefully; during one at least out of the three watches a wise man should be watchful. 158. Let each man direct himself first to what is proper, then let him te…”
Both passages emphasize the importance of self-mastery and inner virtue. They discuss the nature of true wisdom and the importance of aligning oneself with higher principles, whether it be the Heavenly in Chuang Tzu or the teachings of the Buddha in the Dhammapada.
greek_mystery|The Golden Verses of Pythagoras|Section 4 (part 1)
p. 1 THE GOLDEN VERSES OF PYTHAGORAS 1. First worship the Immortal Gods, as they are established and ordained by the Law. 2. Reverence the Oath, and next the Heroes, full of goodness and light. 3. Honour likewise the Terrestrial Dæmon…”
Both passages emphasize the importance of virtue, self-discipline, and harmony with the natural or divine order. They also highlight the significance of understanding and accepting the inevitability of life's circumstances, such as death and fate.
greek_mystery|The Golden Verses of Pythagoras|Section 9 (part 1)
p. 45 PYTHAGOREAN ETHICAL SENTENCES FROM STOBÆUS 1. Do not even think of doing what ought not to be done. 2. Choose rather to be strong in soul than in body. 3. Be persuaded that things of a laborious nature contribute more than pleas…”
Both passages emphasize the importance of virtue, wisdom, and inner strength. They also highlight the transient nature of worldly things and the importance of aligning oneself with higher principles or divine order.
greek_mystery|The Golden Verses of Pythagoras|Section 9 (part 2)
Or in the third place, it is impelled when it is not proper, and to objects to which it ought not to tend. 22. Endeavour not to conceal your errors p. 49 by words, but to remedy them by reproof. 23. It is not so difficult to err, as no…”
Both passages emphasize the importance of virtue, wisdom, and inner harmony. They also highlight the transient nature of life and the need to align oneself with higher principles, whether it be the Heavenly in Chuang Tzu or Divinity in Pythagorean thought.
greek_mystery|The Golden Verses of Pythagoras|Section 11
p. 62 PYTHAGOREAN SENTENCES FROM THE PROTREPTICS OF IAMBLICHUS 1. As we live through soul, it must be said that by the virtue of this we live well; just as because we see through the eyes, we see well through the virtue of these. 2. It must…”
Both passages discuss the qualities and behaviors of enlightened or wise individuals, emphasizing detachment, inner virtue, and alignment with a higher principle (Heaven in Chuang Tzu, God in the other passage). They also highlight the importance of authenticity and the dangers of superficial actions or words.
neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 48
Section 15 15. But suppose two wise men, one of them possessing all that is supposed to be naturally welcome, while the other meets only with the very reverse: do we assert that they have an equal happiness? We do, if they are equally wise.…”
Both passages discuss the qualities and behaviors of the wise or sagely person, emphasizing inner virtue, detachment from external circumstances, and alignment with a higher principle or nature. They share a focus on the sage's equanimity and self-mastery, though they come from different mystical traditions.
neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 165 (part 2)
The more perfect the man, the more compliant he is, even towards his fellows; we must temper our importance, not thrusting insolently beyond what our nature warrants; we must allow other beings, also, their place in the presence of the Godh…”
Both passages emphasize humility, the importance of not elevating oneself above others or the divine, and the need to recognize one's place within the greater order. They both warn against arrogance and self-aggrandizement, advocating instead for harmony and compliance with a higher principle.
neoplatonism|Select Works of Plotinus|Select Works, Section 167
Section 11 11. Now, in the first place, if the Soul has not actually come down but has illuminated the darkness, how can it truly be said to have declined? The outflow from it of something in the nature of light does not justify the asserti…”
Both passages emphasize humility, the importance of not elevating oneself above others or the divine, and the need to recognize one's place within the broader universe or cosmic order. They also warn against false pride and the dangers of self-aggrandizement.
platonism|Plato: Phaedrus|Section 1‚
And this skill he will not attain without a great deal of trouble, which a good man ought to undergo, not for the sake of speaking and acting before men, but in order that he may be able to say what is acceptable to God and always to act ac…”
Both passages discuss the importance of aligning one's actions and speech with divine or higher principles, emphasizing the pursuit of wisdom and virtue over mere human approval or worldly ends. They also touch on the limitations of human inventions and the need for inner cultivation.